|
Of PageRank and International Standards
BERL has made much of how its estimate of the costs of alcohol use in New Zealand is peer reviewed and follows international standards. Let's peel back the sheet a little. Eric Single, in "Why we should still estimate the costs of substance abuse even if we needn't pay undue attention to the bottom line", Drug and Alcohol Review (March 2009), pp. 117-121, writes: In May 1994 the Canadian Centre on Substance Abuse (CCSA) organised an international symposium in Banff, Canada, to discuss the issues involved in estimating the social and economic costs of substance abuse, and to seek a consensus on the most appropriate model. The purpose of the meeting was to explore the feasibility of establishing an internationally acceptable common method for estimating the costs of substance abuse. A working group was formed to explore the potential for developing guidelines on estimating the economic costs of substance abuse, consisting of [Eric Single], David Collins, Brian Easton, Rick Harwood, Helen Lapsley and Alan Maynard. These guidelines were finalised at a second International Symposium held in Montebello, Quebec, in 1996.So the basic method was devised by Single, Collins, Easton, Harwood, Lapsley, Kopp, Wilson and Maynard, and we shouldn't then view these as independent of each other in assessing the appropriateness of their devised method. What are the most cited sources in the BERL report? And of course the external reviewers for the BERL report were David Collins and Helen Lapsley. There's nothing wrong with using a method devised for a purpose and citing the various refinements of that method. But it wouldn't be right to view the varied iterations as independent of each other. And it would be somewhat misleading to describe the method as "internationally accepted" on the basis of a series of commissioned reports in different countries which all cross-reference one-another. If BERL has some other reason to cite international acceptance, it should say what it is. So, arguments that the method has been used by folks all over the world only really mean that the same coterie of consultants has been successful in selling their method to a few different government health departments. In other words, BERL's page rank shouldn't be augmented by this kind of appeal to authority. Yahoo: seo tools Of PageRank and International Standards pagerank Google: pagerank Of PageRank and International Standards seo tools |
Related
›› PageRank - a new addition to your Data P
›› PageRank algorithm finds physics gems
›› Beyond PageRank, RankNet, and fRank
›› Get Google Pagerank 5 in 90 Days
›› Ask's BigNews and a PageRank for news
›› Blog Comment Optimization for HIgher Goo
›› March 09 Google Pagerank Update
›› PageRank - Stop worrying about yours !
›› Selling my soul^H^H^H^H pagerank
›› Trivia: Google PageRank
›› PageRank algorithm finds physics gems
›› Beyond PageRank, RankNet, and fRank
›› Get Google Pagerank 5 in 90 Days
›› Ask's BigNews and a PageRank for news
›› Blog Comment Optimization for HIgher Goo
›› March 09 Google Pagerank Update
›› PageRank - Stop worrying about yours !
›› Selling my soul^H^H^H^H pagerank
›› Trivia: Google PageRank
Seo Latest
›› PageRank - a new addition to your Data P
›› Selling my soul^H^H^H^H pagerank
›› Trivia: Google PageRank
›› Of PageRank and International Standards
›› International Promotions: Powered by GOO
›› What is Web 2.0? why We care for . .
›› SEO Book Aaron Wall
›› Requirent PHP/MySQL, SEO, S/W Testers
›› Persuasion principles
›› 1stPromotion's Integrated Income Syst
›› 150 Social Bookmarking
›› Free SEO Tools - No One Can Beat the Too
›› Selling my soul^H^H^H^H pagerank
›› Trivia: Google PageRank
›› Of PageRank and International Standards
›› International Promotions: Powered by GOO
›› What is Web 2.0? why We care for . .
›› SEO Book Aaron Wall
›› Requirent PHP/MySQL, SEO, S/W Testers
›› Persuasion principles
›› 1stPromotion's Integrated Income Syst
›› 150 Social Bookmarking
›› Free SEO Tools - No One Can Beat the Too
Seo Popular
›› Pay per blog posting and seo?
›› For best SEO is it better to start a new
›› How do the research tools (equipment &am
›› How do I find the "Real" Straw
›› Does Link Popularity Help Your PageRank?
›› What is the best link building method on
›› Where you charged $11.89 from Synergy De
›› Riyasen thunder thies on Ramp
›› Requirent PHP/MySQL, SEO, S/W Testers
›› What is a good beginner electric guitar?
›› Poll: about half of Catholics support No
›› Redirects - do they help with link popul
›› For best SEO is it better to start a new
›› How do the research tools (equipment &am
›› How do I find the "Real" Straw
›› Does Link Popularity Help Your PageRank?
›› What is the best link building method on
›› Where you charged $11.89 from Synergy De
›› Riyasen thunder thies on Ramp
›› Requirent PHP/MySQL, SEO, S/W Testers
›› What is a good beginner electric guitar?
›› Poll: about half of Catholics support No
›› Redirects - do they help with link popul
You may find: